Kirksville Police have made a third arrest in connection with what is believed to be a staged armed robbery that occurred in January. On February 15, 2025, KPD arrested 40-year-old Anthony Lloyd Williams, of Kirksville, for his involvement in the robbery of New Star Mart on January 8, 2025. He has been charged in Adair County with First-Degree Robbery, a Class A felony. Kaydyn Aldridge and James Findling Jr. have previously been charged in connection to this investigation. Aldridge was identified as the suspect who entered the store, threatened to shoot the clerk, then left with an undisclosed amount of cash. Police determined the clerk working at the time of the incident, Findling Jr., was a willing participant in the robbery and is accused of planning the robbery. The continued investigation discovered Williams provided transportation for Aldridge to and from the store. The investigation into the robbery is still active.